If contemplating Beautyrest vs iComfort, you’re comparing mattresses from two major manufacturers, Simmons and Serta. And you are wavering between the traditional innerspring technology versus the now popular memory foam mattress technology. Either choice means a major commitment of your money and time sleeping, so let’s determine which is a better investment for you.

Beautyrest vs iComfort > Comparing Mattress Technology

Beautyrest Mattress versus iComfort MattressWith the introduction of Beautyrest Pocketed Coil technology in 1925, Simmons revolutionized innerspring technology. The high-performance, heavy-gauge coil system allowed for more body conformance yet less motion disturbance, introducing a new level of comfort and support to innerspring mattresses.

With the Beautyrest line of mattresses, they promise to deliver Simmons standards of comfort, support and durability by using luxurious fabrics, durable foams and other high-quality materials, made here in the USA.

On the other hand, the iComfort mattress is constructed with Serta’s Cool Action Gel Memory Foam to provide comfort and support without the heat associated with memory foam. The MicroSupport® gel actually gets infused into the memory foam during production. The iComfort claims to be 25% denser than other brands, offering a richer product with excellent support and durability.

When comparing Beautyrest vs iComfort technology, you have to consider the advantages of an innerspring versus a memory foam mattress. Both models attempt to solve problems identified with its technology in the past. Beautyrest offers greater body conformance and support with less motion disturbance, making it more appealing to memory foam mattress shoppers. And iComfort reduces the heat associated with memory foam using its Cool Action Gel infusion, while offering pressure point relief.

Keep in mind that innerspring mattresses tend to cost less than memory foam. But memory foam mattresses resist dust mites and other allergens, if that feature appeals to you.

Beautyrest vs iComfort > Shopping for Extras

Five different Beautyrest models feature edge support, a no-flip design, Energy Foam for greater stability and Transflexion Comfort Technology for comfort throughout the life of the mattress, along with a 10-year warranty.

The top-of-the-line, Beautyrest Black mattress, offered at Mattress Source locations, also boasts the Recharge Sleep System, promising you will be “Living Life Fully Charged”.

  • AirCool Memory Foam for full body conformance, pressure point and freedom of movement (including a layer of GelTouch foam to help dissipate heat for cooler sleeping)
  • AirCool BeautyEdge Foam Encasement for enhanced airflow throughout the mattress while providing comfort all the way to the edge
  • AirCool Mesh Border Fabric that encases the mattress for greater breathability and airflow

The Serta iComfort mattress features the Cool Action Gel Memory Foam and Ultimate Edge Support for an extended sleep surface, along with a 25-year warranty. Select models of the iComfort line also offer:

  • ComfortLast Foam Core with Ultimate Edge Support for an extended sleep surface
  • KoolComfort Memory Foam for greater body conformance without so much heat
  • Cool Reaction Slow Recovery Latex Foam for naturally hypoallergenic and cooler sleep

Beautyrest vs iComfort > Sleeper Reviews

While customers praise Beautyrest mattresses for comfort and support, some indicate disappointment in durability. Meanwhile, reviews of iComfort praise support and temperature control but complain about the surface integrity and warranty.

When considering Beautyrest vs iComfort, first determine if either technology lacks one of your priorities when it comes to a sleep surface. Because each addresses the usual “cons” within its category, general articles about innerspring vs memory foam may not be as helpful as giving each a 15-minute rest test in stores to determine the best option for you.

Locate a MattressSource Store Near You


The Ultimate Mattress Buying Guide