If you’re comparing a memory foam mattress vs spring, you may be wondering which mattress will best suit your sleep needs. Buying a new mattress means putting your trust and commitment into something you’re going to rely upon for better sleep, and ultimately better quality of life. So let’s take a closer look at a memory foam mattress vs spring to help with this serious decision!

Memory Foam mattress vs springMemory Foam Mattress vs Spring > Reviewing Pros and Complaints

The memory foam mattress has gained popularity in recent years because of its ‘body conformance’, meaning the mattress molds to your body when you lay on it. Body conformance provides your body with support at all points, therefore relieving typical pressure points such as your hips and shoulders. It also absorbs motion better than many innerspring mattresses, which means you’ll feel less motion disturbance from your partner.

Memory Foam Pros

  • Provides optimal pressure point relief (good for back and side sleepers)
  • Minimizes motion disturbance
  • Resists bacteria, mold and dust

Memory Foam Complaints

  • May make sleeping hotter
  • May leave body impressions over time
  • May lack back support
  • Foam surface is NEVER recommended for infants (due to Sudden Infant Death Syndrome concerns)

If you tend to get hot while sleeping, you may want to consider a gel-infused foam mattress like the Restonic CoolGel memory foam mattress. This mattress is designed to dissipate your body’s heat rather than absorb it, allowing you to sleep cooler than on regular memory foam.

As with any product, if it’s made from low-quality materials, it may not perform as well. So by making sure you buy higher density foam, you can help avoid issues with back support or body impressions over time.

Now, still dominating the mattress industry, the traditional innerspring, or spring mattress, comes in a wide range of models to accommodate the sleep needs of any sleeper. Generally, spring mattresses can offer the same benefits of a memory foam mattress, but tend to cost less. It’s just a matter of knowing what benefits you need and which features offer those benefits.

Spring Pros

  • Costs less while providing adequate support and comfort

Spring Complaints

  • May allow more motion disturbance
  • May allow pressure points

Newer spring mattresses attempt to combat these complaints with new designs and features. The Simmons Beautyrest mattress line introduced the pocketed coil design that consists of individually wrapped coils, rather than having them tied together, to enhance body conformance. This helps alleviate pressure points while minimizing motion disturbance.


In a snapshot, on a scale of 1- 5 with 5 being the highest:



Enables cooler sleep
Healthful (less chemicals)
Motion seperation
Pressure Relief


Another option is to buy a spring mattress and add a ’memory foam topper’, which gives you benefits of both mattresses with a less permanent commitment. Or you can consider a pillowtop innerspring mattress for a cradling effect.

Memory Foam Mattress vs Spring > Comparing Construction

Typically made from a visco-elastic substance derived from polyurethane, a memory foam mattress is an open-cell foam that responds to the weight and heat of your body. Once you exit your bed, the mattress cools and returns to its normal shape.

When shopping for a memory foam mattress, look for a mattress with higher quality, or denser foam level. Density levels in a memory foam mattress usually range from 2 to 6 lbs/ft3, with levels over 4 lbs/ft3 indicating a high-quality product. Denser mattresses will typically feel firmer and last longer and cost more, but should perform better.

Although a few companies manufacture natural memory foam, most memory foam mattresses remain man-made.

Now, the spring mattress uses the support of tempered steel coils attached to a strong border wire and/or foam encasement to retain the mattress shape and prevent sagging. Then upholstery layers are added on top to produce a comfortable, supportive sleep surface.

Manufacturers use a variety of spring, or coil, shapes to construct spring mattresses.

  • The original, Bonnell coil system, sports an hourglass shaped spring with a knot at each end of the coils, and will usually cost less.
  • The Offset coil contains hourglass shaped springs with flattened edges at the top and bottom for a more efficient hinging action, and therefore greater body conformance.
  • The Pocketed coil design individually wraps each coil within its own pocket, allowing independent coil movement and decreased motion disturbance.

If you’re still unsure whether a memory foam mattress vs spring mattress is best for you, download for FREE this step-by-step mattress buying guide to help you decide. Or visit a Mattress Source location nearest you today. A salesperson will be happy to help you, and let your perform a 15-minute rest test on any memory foam mattress vs spring before you commit. It’s a big decision, and Mattress Source will help you find the best mattress for you at the best price.


Locate a MattressSource Store Near You

The Ultimate Mattress Buying Guide